I don't really have as big of a problem with Amtrak as some others. While its not as cheap as I'd like, the amenities between Boston and NYC are actually pretty good. I'm speaking specifically about the Acela Express, which is business and first class only between the two cities.
Firstly, unlike the regional, once outside of Boston, it makes few stops: Providence, New Haven, Stamford and NYC. This prevents delays which are typical of Amtrak. South Station is downtown near where I work and Penn Station is in the middle of Manhattan, eliminating 30 minutes of travel time to/from the airports. I simply walk into the train station 2 minutes before my train departs and board, eliminating the pesky and timely security checks at the airport. The train has plenty of space. The cabin isn't pressurized. I can use my electronics from the get-go (though I think they should add wi-fi at this point). Really, all-in-all, its not that bad...its actually pretty good.
The biggest complaint I hear from friends is the price. "Why pay $100 for a train ticket, when I can pay $80 and fly there in 45 minutes?". Leaving aside the time added by security and travel to/from the airport, the cost argument just doesn't work. If you buy far enough in advance, the train ticket is always under $100. I bought my ticket yesterday and it was $107. If you buy a voucher pack of airline shuttle tickets, maybe it averages out to $80 per ticket, but this includes the cab ride to Logan (at least $15) and the cab from LaGuardia (I think it's about $25 plus tip). That puts the plane ticket at $120. If its a round trip, that's $80 of cab fares. The train is significantly cheaper.
I just don't get why people hate it so much. Must be a perception thing.
-------------------------
Sent using BlackBerry Wireless

